Imagine diligently saving up for retirement, using all the tools and incentives offered by tax laws, including deferred taxation of your earnings. Now imagine you’re told by Uncle Sam, “It’s time to pay the piper on those earnings!” That’s the idea behind required minimum distributions (RMDs). They ensure you eventually pay taxes on your retirement savings. It seems reasonable, right? But it’s essential to consider all the implications of RMDs.
How RMDs Work and Their Implications for Planning
RMD rules apply for employer-sponsored retirement plans, such as 401(k), 403(b), profit-sharing plans, and traditional IRAs. The RMD formula for determining how much you are required to withdraw each year is based on your retirement account balance and life expectancy. Here’s how it works:
The Age Factor
The current age at which to begin taking distributions is 73 (the initial age requirement of 70 1/2 was increased to age 73 by the SECURE 2.0 Act). This means that once you reach age 73, the IRS requires you to withdraw a minimum amount from your retirement accounts each year. Failing to do so results in a hefty penalty of 25% of the undistributed amount.
The Calculation
The RMD amount is calculated based on a formula that considers two key factors:
- Your Retirement Account Balance: The total value of your traditional IRA or 401(k) at the end of the prior year is used.
- Your Life Expectancy: The IRS publishes life expectancy tables. These tables estimate how many more years you are likely to live based on your current age.
The Formula
Divide your retirement account balance by your life expectancy factor from the IRS table to arrive at your RMD for that year. This amount represents the minimum you must withdraw and can be distributed in a lump sum or spread throughout the year. You can also use an RMD calculator widely available online.
It’s also essential to remember that if you own multiple retirement accounts, required minimum distributions must be calculated separately for each.
A Real-Life Example
For example, consider a 73-year-old retiree with $800,000 in her 401(k) at the end of last year. According to the IRS tables, her life expectancy might be around 14.3 years. To calculate her RMD, she divides her account balance by that number to get an RMD of roughly $19,047. She has the option of taking this out all at once each year or spreading it out monthly.
The RMD Dilemma
The problem is that this calculation might force you to take out more money than you need, requiring you to pay taxes you would have preferred to defer. That means your future income potential takes a hit. The good news is that you have some flexibility in how you take your RMDs.
The big question is: Is it better to take RMD monthly or annually?
Annual RMDs vs. Monthly RMDs
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best approach depends on your individual circumstances, financial goals, and risk tolerance. Let’s delve into the pros and cons of each approach to help you decide what’s right for you.
The Case for Annual RMDs
Here are some of the advantages of annual RMDs:
Tax Efficiency
Leaving your money invested in your retirement account for as long as possible allows it to grow tax-deferred. This can be particularly beneficial if you’re in a lower tax bracket now than you anticipate later in retirement. Deferring withdrawals can maximize your long-term retirement nest egg.
Investment Strategy Flexibility
Taking your RMD as a lump sum gives you more control over how you invest it. You can reinvest it in your retirement account or use it for other investments that align better with your current goals.
Additionally, delaying your RMD until later in the year can enable you to maximize the growth of your retirement savings and see your full-year income picture to potentially minimize the tax impact.
Simpler Record Keeping
Tracking a single annual withdrawal is easier than managing multiple monthly distributions. This can be especially helpful if you have multiple retirement accounts.
Things to Consider with Annual Distributions
Here are some of the possible downsides of annual distributions:
Potential for Higher Taxes
If you’re already in a high tax bracket or expect your income to increase in retirement, taking a large annual RMD could bump you into a higher tax bracket, negating some of the tax benefits of deferral.
Market Fluctuations
If you withdraw a significant amount in a down-market year, it could lock in those losses and potentially hinder your portfolio’s recovery. Consider dollar-cost averaging throughout the year to mitigate this risk.
Discipline Required
The temptation to spend the annual RMD distribution instead of reinvesting it can be overwhelming. Having a concrete plan for the RMD ensures it goes towards your retirement goals.
The Case for Monthly RMDs
The advantages of monthly RMDs include:
Spreading Out Tax Burden
By taking smaller monthly withdrawals, you may be able to distribute the tax impact across multiple tax brackets, potentially minimizing your overall tax liability.
Income Stream Consistency
Monthly RMDs create a more predictable income stream, which can be helpful for budgeting and managing your monthly expenses in retirement. This can be particularly appealing if you don’t have a pension or other reliable sources of income.
Reduced Market Impact
Spreading out your withdrawals throughout the year reduces the impact of any single market downturn. This can provide peace of mind and help your portfolio weather market fluctuations.
Things to Consider with Monthly RMDs
There are a few potential downsides to be aware of if you choose to take monthly RMDs:
Increased Record-Keeping
Tracking and managing multiple monthly withdrawals can be more complex than managing a single annual sum. To simplify the process, consider using budgeting tools or working with a financial advisor.
Potential for Lower Returns
Taking out smaller amounts more frequently means less money remains invested and compounding in your retirement accounts. This could have a slight negative impact on your long-term growth.
Investment Fees
More frequent withdrawals could incur more transaction fees, depending on your investment platform’s structure.
Additional Factors to Consider
Your age: Younger retirees may benefit more from tax deferral offered by annual lump sums to maximize long-term growth. Older retirees with a steady income stream may prefer the predictability of monthly distributions.
Your retirement expenses: If you have consistent retirement expenses, monthly RMDs can help with budgeting. If your expenses are variable, a lump sum might offer more flexibility.
Your risk tolerance: Those uncomfortable with market volatility might favor monthly RMDs to lessen the impact of potential market downturns. Investors with a higher risk tolerance might prefer the potential for growth with a lump sum.
Strategies to Avoid or Reduce RMDs
Even after you cross the retirement threshold, you still have options for avoiding RMDs or mitigating their tax implications. One option is to convert your traditional IRA or 401(k) to a Roth IRA. The second option is to use a Qualified Longevity Annuity Contract. Here’s how these planning tools work:
Converting to a Roth IRA to Avoid RMDs
You could consider converting all or a portion of your traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA. The primary reason for doing so is that income withdrawals from a Roth are tax-exempt. That’s because contributions to a Roth are made with after-tax dollars. When you convert to a Roth from a traditional IRA or a 401k plan, you are required to pay a tax now on the total gain in the account.
That may seem like a big sacrifice for most people, but it may be worth considering now before federal taxes are increased. Having your money in a Roth IRA also protects your income against future tax increases. You can use a Roth conversion calculator available online to determine if this would benefit you in the long run.
Make Qualified Charitable Distributions
While you can’t escape taxes forever, there’s a way to fulfill your RMD requirement and support a cause you care about – all while potentially lowering your tax burden. Enter the Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD).
A QCD allows you to donate directly from your IRA to a qualified charity up to $105,000 annually (as of 2024). The donated amount counts towards your required minimum distribution for the year. But here’s the kicker: unlike regular IRA withdrawal, the qualified charitable distribution amount isn’t taxed. This can significantly lower your taxable income, potentially pushing you into a lower tax bracket and saving you money.
By strategically using QCDs, you can achieve two goals simultaneously. First, you support a worthy cause close to your heart. Second, you reduce your overall tax liability, potentially leaving more money in your pocket. This can be especially beneficial if your RMD pushes you into a higher tax bracket. It’s a win-win for both your charitable spirit and your retirement savings.
If charitable giving is part of your vision, QCDs can be a powerful tool to fulfill those wishes while minimizing your tax burden.
Using a QLAC to Stretch Your RMDs and Protect Against Longevity
Think of a QLAC as a special retirement account you buy with funds from your IRA or 401(k). The key difference? You get to delay taking withdrawals until a much later date (up to age 85) compared to the earlier deadlines set by RMDs. This allows your remaining retirement savings to continue growing tax-deferred for longer.
Transferring a portion of your retirement savings to a QLAC effectively reduces the account balance used to calculate your annual required minimum distributions, resulting in lower mandatory withdrawals each year. You can then use the remaining funds in your IRA or 401(k) more strategically, potentially stretching them further throughout your retirement.
QLACs aren’t perfect. Fees are involved, and access to your money is limited until the payout starts. However, for those concerned about RMDs forcing them to spend down their savings too quickly, QLACs offer a compelling option to consider.
Making the Right Choice
Ultimately, the best approach depends on your unique circumstances. Here are some additional tips to guide you:
Consult a Financial Advisor
A qualified financial advisor can help you analyze your situation, risk tolerance, and retirement goals to recommend the most suitable RMD withdrawal strategy.
Consider Tax Implications
Run different scenarios using tax planning software or consult a tax professional to estimate the potential tax impact of each approach.
Review Regularly
Your RMD withdrawal strategy may need to be adjusted over time as your financial situation, tax bracket, and retirement goals evolve.
Remember, the IRS simply requires that your entire RMD be withdrawn by the end of the calendar year. You have the flexibility to choose the option that works best for you.
Factoring RMDs into your retirement income planning is crucial to avoid penalties and ensure your savings last throughout your retirement. Discussing RMD strategies with your financial advisor is essential for optimizing your tax situation. We invite you to contact a retirement planner at ARQ Wealth to discuss how the RMD change impacts your specific situation.
Contact Us Today! (480) 289-6865
